Nobody wants to have “that conversation.” You know the one—where you have to explain buyer agency agreements, discuss commission structures, or navigate the awkward moment when a client starts questioning your value. For many real estate agents, these conversations feel like walking through a minefield of potential objections and misunderstandings.
But what if those challenging moments could become your greatest opportunity to build trust? Bill Gallagher, North Carolina’s legendary real estate educator and Distinguished Real Estate Instructor, has spent decades teaching agents how to transform uncomfortable conversations into connection points for building rapport with clients.
Gallagher’s approach isn’t about perfect scripts or pushy sales tactics. Instead, he approaches these conversations by building genuine rapport, honest communication, and creating space for clients to feel heard and understood.
This piece explores Gallagher’s time-tested strategies for building authentic relationships with buyers, handling the new agency agreement requirements with confidence, and turning every client interaction into a foundation for long-term success.
Key Takeaways
- Start with a Genuine Connection: Build rapport by asking about clients’ motivations and truly listening to their responses before diving into paperwork or processes.
- Make Agency Agreements Less Intimidating: Offer flexible terms like one-day or single-property agreements to help new clients feel comfortable while you both establish trust.
- Use Active Listening to Guide Your Marketing: When working with sellers, let their reasons for buying the home shape how you market it to potential buyers.
- Address Commission Conversations Head-On: Explain the new compensation structures clearly and help clients understand that commission costs are typically built into home prices regardless of who pays them.
- Position Yourself as a Protective Guide: Frame your role as someone who helps clients avoid trauma and drama by being proactive about inspections, title work, and potential issues.
Start With Connection, Not Contracts
The biggest mistake agents make? Jumping straight to business. Gallagher’s approach flips the script entirely.
Here’s an example of how Gallagher begins a conversation with a new buyer client:
“It’s great to meet you in person. I know we talked on the phone and had a wonderful conversation, and I just want to thank you for this opportunity to meet you and discuss your needs, your wants, and your desires. And if you could, just kind of summarize what you’re looking for in your new home.”
Notice what he doesn’t do here. No immediate mention of agency agreements. No pressure to sign anything. Just genuine curiosity about what matters to his client.
How to apply this approach
Before you even think about paperwork, spend time understanding your client’s story. Ask about their lifestyle, their family, and their dreams for their new home.
This isn’t just nice-to-have small talk. It’s strategic relationship building that pays dividends throughout the entire transaction.
Navigate Agency Agreements With Flexibility
Here’s where Gallagher’s brilliance really shines. Instead of treating the new buyer agency requirements like an obstacle, he frames them as an opportunity to build trust gradually.
Here’s an example of how Gallagher explains this NAR requirement:
“I’m here to help lead and guide you, but it’s your decision. I just want to let you know, we do need to sign a written buyer agency agreement before I show you the first property. I’ll let you read it. Take it with you so you can feel good, feel comfortable. But just keep in mind, I want you to know that I just met you, and you just met me. And if you’d like to have a get-to-know period, I would be more than happy to sign a written by agreement for one day or for one property showing.”
Breaking down the brilliance
Gallagher acknowledges the awkwardness head-on. He doesn’t pretend this requirement is no big deal. Instead, he:
- Gives the client control (“It’s your decision”)
- Explains the requirement clearly
- Offers flexibility with short-term agreements
- Uses relatable language (“Get-to-know period”)
The result? Instead of resistance, clients feel understood and protected.
Turn Listening Into Marketing Gold
Gallagher’s approach to listing conversations reveals another layer of strategic thinking. He starts by asking what originally drew the homeowner to their current property. He then takes notes and explains how he’ll use that information.
“I took some notes on what you said, and I will focus our marketing, our advertisements on why you bought this home. And I heard you say, you were drawn to the property for the large eat-in kitchen, and entertaining areas perfect for conversations, parties, and get-togethers. Is that what I heard you say?”
The power of mirroring
By repeating back what he heard and asking for confirmation, Gallagher:
- Shows he was actively listening
- Gets the seller to reinforce their key selling points
- Creates buy-in for the marketing strategy
- Builds confidence in his approach
This technique works because people want to feel heard. When you mirror their language and priorities back to them, they feel understood and more likely to trust your guidance.
Handle Commission Conversations Like a Pro
The new commission landscape has many agents tongue-tied. Not Gallagher. He tackles it directly with clear explanations and practical examples.
“What that means for you is, as a buyer, this agreement says that you will pay the firm a fee of blank percent or a flat fee. We will first seek that fee from the seller, from the listing firm, from the builder, from the for sale by owner, and ask them how much they will cooperate and compensate us in this transaction.”
Breaking it down further
Gallagher doesn’t stop at the mechanics. He explains the bigger picture:
“A lot of builders have always paid compensation. The sellers have paid, and hopefully, they will continue to pay. But the seller has the right to say, ‘hey, I will not pay the commission.’ Therefore, the buyer would basically pay us per this agreement.
However, keep in mind that the commission is really built into the price. If commission is built into the price, and you pay the price, then indirectly you’re paying the commission.”
This explanation helps clients understand that they’re not getting something for free when sellers pay commission. They’re getting a service that’s already factored into the home’s price.
Become the “Trauma and Drama” Prevention Specialist
During conversations with potential clients, Gallagher consistently positions himself as someone who helps clients avoid problems before they happen. Whether it’s recommending pre-inspections, title searches, or explaining financing options, he’s always thinking ahead.
He tells clients that he would rather be proactive rather than reactive.
The psychology of protection
When clients see you as someone who anticipates and prevents problems, they’re more likely to:
- Trust your recommendations
- Follow your guidance
- Refer you to others
- Work with you again in the future
Handle Objections with Grace and Understanding
Real estate agents need to learn how to answer common objections. For example, many clients may have a “friend in the business.” Here’s how to acknowledge the relationship while explaining the potential risks of working with a real estate agent you know personally:
“You’re going to probably share a lot of confidential information with me, a lot of top-secret information that you don’t want really friends to know or be basically part of. Also, I would not want you to run the risk of losing a friend over a real estate transaction because it’s going to get emotional sometimes.”
Instead, Gallagher advises homeowners with friends in the business to get involved in the transaction by bringing a buyer to the property.
The collaborative approach
Notice how Gallagher doesn’t dismiss the friend or badmouth the competition. Instead, he does the following:
- Validates the client’s feelings
- Explains potential risks thoughtfully
- Offers a win-win solution (friend brings buyer, Gallagher lists)
- Maintains professionalism throughout
Your Next Steps for Building Better Client Relationships
Gallagher’s approach isn’t about memorizing scripts or using manipulative tactics. It’s about genuine human connection, clear communication, and positioning yourself as a trusted advisor who puts the client’s needs first.
The real estate industry is changing rapidly, and the agents who thrive will be those who can navigate these changes while building authentic relationships. Start by listening more, explaining clearly, and always looking for ways to serve your clients’ best interests. When you approach every conversation with genuine care and professional expertise, those awkward moments transform into opportunities to demonstrate your value and build lasting trust.
As Gallagher would say, “It’s going to be a fun experience.” And when you approach client relationships with that kind of positive energy and professional confidence, it usually is.
Ready to kickstart your real estate career and avoid the common pitfalls new agents face? Enroll in the Survive & Thrive Real Estate Course by Colibri Real Estate School—a real-world, results-driven program designed to help you land clients faster and build a thriving business.
What you’ll gain:
- Real confidence when talking to prospects and clients
- A lead generation strategy that actually works
- Tools to grow referrals and lasting business relationships
- Scripts, templates, and a clear roadmap to take action immediately
What’s included:
- Lead Tracker & CRM Template
- Agent Scripts for Outreach & Conversion
- Buyer/Seller Consultation Templates
- Sales Pitch Frameworks, Agent Success Stories, and more!
- Plus, a free DISC Personality Assessment for stronger client connections
With a money-back guarantee, you’ve got nothing to lose—but everything to gain.
You’re not alone in this. Learn from successful agents who’ve been where you are now and discover the exact steps to go from your first sale to $10M in transactions.
